This past Sunday, Alberta officially moved to Permanent Daylight Time. I was half-jokingly grumbling to my friend that we were not getting our hour back from the spring, when I started to become curious about whether this was a change that was better for my health or not. A few days into the new shift (or lack thereof), I find it confusing and there are definitely some minor tech hiccups so far. But what about our biological clock? Is it better for your health to not switch back and forth seasonally? Or did the spring and fall time change provide us with a better potential for health benefit up until now? The answer may surprise you.
(Short on time? Click here for The Bottom Line)
Although new to Alberta, Permanent Daylight Time is not so new in Canada. The rollout started in 2020, when the Yukon abandoned changing with the seasons. BC and the Northwest Territories followed suit. It’s happened around the world before as well. Mexico in 2022 and Brazil in 2019 both changed to Permanent Standard Time, while Türkiye in 2016 and Jordan in 2022 changed to Permanent Daylight Time.
I think that is the first key to understanding the confusion or answering whether this move is good for your health or not. Was it a switch to Permanent Daylight Time or Permanent Standard Time? Of course in Alberta, it was the former, unfortunately making this more confusing. Let’s dive in.
On the surface there is an obvious benefit: no more dealing with changing clocks, sadly losing an hour of sleep, then happily regaining that hour, and all the other logistics involved. As we look at the evidence for your health, it gets both better and worse.
- What gets better? There is less of a spike in heart attacks, strokes, and fatal car crashes, which were previously related to the time changes twice a year!
- What gets worse? The Permanent Daylight Time part is problematic for your health. Your circadian rhythm is disrupted, you and your work and/or social schedule experiences a form of chronic jetlag, and your biological clock and alarm clock are out of sync.
Unfortunately, there is more that gets worse. Before we digest that together, let’s learn a little bit of background. Are you familiar with the circadian rhythm?
Your circadian rhythm is like a master clock or timekeeper that is built into your body. It is located in the Brain, specifically in the Hypothalamus. Your internal clock is your Suprachiasmatic Nucleus (SCN), which syncs to natural light as it hits the retina at the back of your eyes. Your internal clock takes in information from eating regular meals, your movement and energy levels, your hormones, and your sleep, to keep everything running as smoothly as possible.
So, what exactly is the problem? Permanent Daylight Time delays these crucial morning light cues your brain relies on. This is precisely what pushes your body’s clock and the wall clock out of alignment.
During winter in Alberta, sunrise can be as late as 10AM, meaning your normal awakening response (via cortisol) and your clearance of melatonin from the night are delayed. Basically, you are going to get up for work or school before sunrise, and your body will think and feel like it is still nighttime. You will also likely end up commuting, working, and being expected to function in “biological nighttime”.
On the way home from work or school, you have more light in the evening (which I know sounds good), but results in your natural melatonin release being later on. This creates a feeling of jetlag without traveling that becomes chronic and is hard to get rid of… especially since work and school times do not change.
Aside from the reasonable, obvious assumption that having your biological clock and wall clock in alignment is good for your health (it is), what does this really matter? Here’s the part I really don’t like:
If your circadian rhythm is thrown off, there is a ripple effect throughout the body. And this is where the disruption to your metabolic health and risk of chronic disease worsens. Some scenarios:
- Increased Insulin Resistance = Higher risk of Obesity, Type 2 Diabetes, and Metabolic Syndrome.
- Dysregulated Appetite = You feel more hungry, less full, and may have a higher risk of craving refined carbohydrates in the evening.
- Reduced Heart Health = Higher risk of elevated Blood Pressure, Inflammation, and direct damage to your blood vessels.
- Impacted Mental Health = Worsening of Seasonal Affective Disorders or Depression, especially in the winter.
Okay look, it is not all doom and gloom. I understand these health risks are serious and if you feel annoyed, you are preaching to the choir. However, my hope is to educate and empower you to take charge of your health and focus on what you can control.
As always, here are your preventative habits to help you get ahead of the risks we learned about today:
- Do your best to get bright light in your first hour after waking up in the morning. You may consider trying out a light-therapy lamp (if you do, look for 10,000 Lux and UV free).
- Stay in control of your evening lighting. Use warm-yellow lights and dim ceiling and overhead lighting if possible. And I know you hear it everywhere but yes, of course, please also reduce screen time in your last hour before sleep.
- Try setting a set wake up time and set bed time. I know this is not always practical, so consider a set time window for both, that gives you a range you can at least accomplish more sustainably.
- Do not eat too close to bedtime. Ideally your last meal is 2-3 hours before sleeping, which helps your biological clock wind down in sync with your metabolic clock.
It is great that we don’t have to switch clocks twice a year, but moving to Permanent Daylight Time really comes with some long-term health effects you should be aware of. The scientific bodies and evidence-based recommendations are clear and actually suggest Permanent Standard Time is a better option for your health that also gets rid of the switching clocks headache.
Fun fact: did you know Russia tried out Permanent Daylight Time around 2011? After three years of higher rates of depression, car accidents, and chronic circadian rhythm disruptions, they actually switched over to Permanent Standard Time in 2014!
The takeaway is this: Much of the power to manage your health still remains in your hands. Being proactive about your sleep hygiene, now more than ever, and having a solid morning and evening routine is your strongest pathway towards optimal health and day to day function.
As always, chase progress, not perfection.
I believe in you,
Dr. Khimji
This Week’s Challenge
Set a consistent wake up time every day this week and try to get up at that time regardless of your bedtime the prior evening (within reason; use your judgement).
The Bottom Line
Is the shift to Permanent Daylight Time in Alberta good or bad for your health? Of course it is logistically much nicer to not change times twice a year, every year. Although there are some transition hiccups for sure. My bigger curiosity is around how it affects your health. No time change means less acute events like heart attacks and strokes, but it really depends on which time was chosen. And between Permanent Daylight Time vs Permanent Standard Time, I think we might have chosen the less beneficial one for our health!! Living in daylight time means your internal body clock (circadian rhythm, rooted in your brain) is out of sync with both the clock on your phone and the metabolic clock your body follows based on energy, meals, etc. Your brain relies on natural light when you first wake up to naturally raise your cortisol to a healthy steady amount, and less light before you sleep to help you release your own melatonin. Without these in alignment, you will be functioning in “Daylight” when your body thinks it is night time. Disrupting your circadian rhythm leads to higher rates of Obesity, Diabetes, Insulin Resistance, Disordered Eating, Cardiac Disease, and Depression. The best thing you can do is to be proactive and prevent or reduce these risks. Consider a light-therapy lamp for your first hour awake, dim lights in the evening before you sleep, try having a set wake and sleep time window, and try not to eat too close to sleep time. Focus on what is in your control and I hope your sleep and clocks are as optimal as possible!
